Skip to main content

The Atlanta Shooting - First order or second order racism?

 Here's one of the things that bothers me about the coverage of the Atlanta Shooting: it's being portrayed as a direct result of racism against Asian Americans and Pacific Islanders (AAPI), but I'm bothered by that interpretation.  I don't have a determined position on this, but I'd like to hear any other perspectives that might clarify the situation.  The shooter targeted massage parlors, as part of his own crusade against sex work.  The fact that six of the eight people killed were Asian American women isn't a statistical fluke.  Massage parlors are frequently fronts for sex work, and the women employed in them are frequently trafficked from Asia to work there.  Given the shooter's stated motivation, it seems he was going after sex workers, rather than AAPI people.  The fact that these women were Asian didn't have anything to do with why they died, as a first order cause.  If the women working there had been African-American, or White, or Latinx, or any other ethnicity, they would have been just as dead.  However, the reason they were there and perceived as sex workers (which we don't even know for certain) was because they were AAPI.  This is one of those situations that's a lot more complex than most of the reporting wants to address.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

What I Believe, Part One I've had a number of people tell me I should start a blog.  I don't know if that's a good reason to actually start a blog, but I do a lot of thinking and it would be useful to nail down some of these thoughts.  Inviting comment from others is a good next step. I plan to discuss many topics here, so the first thing I want to do is lay out exactly how I look at the world. First, I took the title for this blog from a series of books that were a great influence on me at a young age.  I just wish the original author actually applied some of the ideals from those books in his own life. The most important thing to remember is that we all have some basic structure we apply to the world and what we expect from it.  Philosophy calls this worldview or paradigm or Weltanschauung, if you're feeling fancy (it's just worldview in German). It's the basis of any philosophy because it defines what you think the universe looks like and the rule

Christianity and State Power

 I woke up in the middle of the night and, unable to return to sleep, stumbled across this article on Facebook: https://www.politicalorphans.com/the-article-removed-from-forbes-why-white-evangelicalism-is-so-cruel/ (HT to Cameron McCoy for sharing that). This line in particular struck me: "If all you knew about Christianity came from a close reading of the New Testament, you’d expect that Christians would be hostile to wealth, emphatic in protection of justice, sympathetic to the point of personal pain toward the sick, persecuted and the migrant, and almost socialist in their economic practices." One of the major problems I have with the pro-birth movement (I refuse to call them pro-life, because most of them quit caring after birth) is their willingness to use state power to enforce their beliefs, which includes the prosecution of doctors (and eventually women, just you wait) for terminating pregnancies.  Many of the people in this movement also abhor using taxes to support